The engagement of NFL star Travis Kelce and global pop icon Taylor Swift has sparked massive attention worldwide. But while fans are celebrating the couple’s happy news, one of Kelce’s former partners has shared a cautionary message directed at Swift.
Maya Benberry, who briefly dated Kelce after winning his 2016 reality dating show Catching Kelce, described the Kansas City Chiefs tight end as a “cheating narcissist.” In an interview, she warned Swift:
“Only time will tell, but like the saying goes, once a cheater, always a cheater. I wish her the best of luck, but I wouldn’t be a girls’ girl if I didn’t advise her to be smart.”
Benberry’s remarks have reignited conversations about Kelce’s dating history. Although her relationship with the NFL star was short-lived, her outspoken comments stand in contrast to those of another of Kelce’s high-profile exes, Kayla Nicole.
Nicole, who dated Kelce on and off from 2017 to 2022, has taken a more reflective tone. Earlier this year, she admitted the constant comparisons to Taylor Swift were “exhausting” and made her question her self-worth. On her podcast, Nicole spoke about the challenges of moving forward while facing public scrutiny, ultimately emphasizing personal growth and resilience.
Meanwhile, Kelce and Swift appear focused on their future together. Their engagement, confirmed earlier this week, was celebrated widely on social media with the viral caption: “Your English teacher and your gym teacher are getting married.”
For now, the spotlight remains firmly on Swift and Kelce, but the voices of their past partners continue to fuel headlines and online debates.
